Insurance Insider: Carving out a category leader and supporting the next phase of growth

Almost two years on from ECI’s investment in January 2025, Insurance Insider is now a standalone company with an eight-strong leadership team, a fully redesigned customer experience, accelerating organic growth and a busy M&A pipeline.

We chat with Toby Fitzherbert, Investment Director at ECI, to discuss how the team delivered the carve-out from Delinian and where the business is heading next, with reflections from Mariana Valle, CEO of Insurance Insider.

Give us a quick overview of Insurance Insider: what does the business do and why were ECI excited to invest? 

Insurance Insider is the leading digital intelligence, insights and data platform for the global specialty insurance market. We were immediately excited when we first identified the business back in 2024 through our Data subsector network when it was part of Delinian. Insurance Insider had shown consistent organic growth with clear opportunities to accelerate.

Alongside this, the resilience case was clear. Their high quality journalism, data and analysis are key to decision-making within the specialty insurance market, and their customers love the product; it has a subscription-based revenue model with very strong retention metrics.

We met Mariana Valle, CEO, to discuss how we could bring our experience in the Data subsector to bear, helping Insurance Insider in its ambition to become the Bloomberg of insurance. We also identified a fantastic Chair for the business, Hamilton Matthews, the former CEO of Acuris and a leader in the financial data space. We built strong conviction through these discussions and ultimately completed the investment through a bilateral process at the start of 2025.

How were you able to deliver a successful carve-out and what were the key steps in the process?

Making sure we could support Mariana and the team to operate Insurance Insider as an independent entity was vital to our due diligence. The carve-out required significant planning and resources to ensure the team’s growth wasn’t derailed by the scale of the project.

One of the most important factors for success was the people involved. Our Commercial Team were instrumental here, with Rich Pearce leading the carve-out workstream. Importantly, this started well before we invested. We brought in specialist carve-out due diligence providers alongside the usual diligence suite, ensuring the full scale of the project was mapped and costed before the deal completed. A full interim leadership team, including a PMO lead, interim CFO, HR Director and IT Director, was in place before the deal was signed. This meant the interim management team could take on the heavy lifting of the separation, so the day-to-day management team could stay focused on running the business and driving growth.

A carve-out was new territory for many of us, but from our very first meeting it was clear ECI would be with us every step of the way. From bringing in excellent interim support to putting the right governance rhythm in place to deliver the plan, they were hands-on throughout. Carve-outs are hugely disruptive and demanding for a management team and the wider business. Getting the right support in place from day one is essential.

Mariana Valle

CEO, Insurance Insider

Equally important was a laser focus on risk. Costs can spiral quickly in a carve-out if separation expenses and ongoing operating costs haven’t been properly scoped. IT licence costs per head change at a smaller scale business, employee benefits need detailed costing, and office moves need realistic estimates. Beyond cost, there are cyber risks from setting up new IT infrastructure, business disruption from system migrations, and people disruption as roles adapt to a new structure. All of this had to be managed without consuming too much of the management team’s time. 

After nine months, the carve-out was completed on time and on budget, and Insurance Insider was operating as an entirely standalone business in its brand new offices in the City, New York and Bulgaria. To the management team’s credit, the business continued to trade well, which gave us great encouragement in our investment thesis. 

How has ECI supported Insurance Insider post carve-out?

We always knew we were backing a great team, and part of our focus post-carve-out has been strengthening this even further with high-calibre hires. We’ve supported Mariana in hiring a permanent CFO and building a full finance function from scratch, developing the HR function, investing in the sales and commercial teams, and strengthening product and technology leadership. In just the last month, Insurance Insider announced the appointment of Jonathan Goor, who previously worked in senior roles at data businesses Acuris and With Intelligence, as COO.

Technology is so important to how Insurance Insider delivers proprietary data and sector-leading content to its customers. Post-carve-out, the team have already launched Insurance Insider 2.0, a redesigned platform with improved UI/UX and increased personalisation, making sure the information they’re reading is bespoke to their needs. Insurance Insider 3.0 is already in the works, building further on its AI and data capabilities to serve more relevant information to customers. ECI’s full suite of Growth Specialists have also been closely involved: Orlando Machado, our AI & Data specialist, has supported the team on operational efficiencies and AI adoption; Gillian Fox, our People & Culture specialist, has helped to build the HR function from scratch and scale; Chris Ginnelly, our Sales & Marketing specialist, has helped the team to hire and expand into the US; our Cyber specialist, Ash Patel, supported on cyber and IT set-up post carve-out; and Badr Khan, our Tech specialist, has joined the Board as a non-executive director to strengthen tech governance.

What comes next at Insurance Insider? 

Insurance Insider 3.0 represents the next major step. The business holds over 30 years of proprietary content and intelligence, sourced directly from insurers through deep industry relationships. This insight and data is incredibly valuable and cannot be replicated by competitors or AI. Mariana and the team are working to leverage this data to launch a new generation of data and AI products, including an MCP (Model Context Protocol) to embed Insurance Insider’s intelligence into customer AI workflows, and deliver its content more intelligently.

What I’m proudest of is our people, and how much we’ve achieved in so little time. We stood the business up on its own two feet while still growing the core and pushing ahead with our value creation plan. And we did it without losing the excitement, ambition and positive culture that make Insurance Insider the business it is. The next 18 months are hugely exciting for us: we’re launching AI-enabled products that plug directly into our clients’ workflows, powered by our 30-year archive of proprietary intelligence. We’re also expanding into adjacent markets whilst continuing to grow our US presence, and actively exploring strategic acquisitions.

Mariana Valle

CEO, Insurance Insider

International expansion is also on the agenda, and in particular we are supporting the business to expand in the US, which is its fastest-growing geography, and they recently successfully launched their New York conference. The Commercial Team is working with management on key product extensions, including the asset management side of the insurance market. There is significant further opportunity across the US and in other geographies, including in Asia. Alongside organic growth initiatives, M&A is absolutely on the table, and the ECI Origination Team is working closely with management to identify selective acquisitions that can accelerate international expansion and build out capabilities.

Insurance Insider is already well on its journey from a specialist intelligence provider to a data and AI-led market intelligence platform with global reach. We have been delighted to support Mariana and the team to date and look forward to what comes next. 

About the author

Toby Fitzherbert

"I am a Director in the Investment Team at ECI having joined in 2018. My role involves meeting and investing in exciting, market-leading, high growth businesses and their great management teams, as well as supporting that team throughout the investment journey."

View Full Profile

Contact Us







    ECI invests in leading accountancy, tax and business advisory firm

    Read more here